Clinical Scenario

A 66-year-old man, heavy smoker, presents with a several-month history of cramping pain in his right calf that comes on after walking a fixed distance and eases with rest. He has come to clinic now because he can no longer walk to the shops.

Take a focused history from this patient and answer the examiner’s questions.

Related Differentials · Same Topic
The examiner could set this station around a different diagnosis within the same presenting complaint. Know how each would change the history.
Differential What would point to it in the history Management in brief
Intermittent claudication — peripheral arterial disease (this case)Cramping calf pain at a fixed, reproducible distance, relieved within minutes by standing still; worse uphill and in the cold; smoker with atherosclerotic risk factorsConservative: smoking cessation, supervised exercise programme, clopidogrel and high-intensity statin, risk-factor control. Surgical: angioplasty ± stent for short lesions, bypass for long occlusions — only if lifestyle-limiting and exercise has failed
Chronic limb-threatening ischaemiaRest pain relieved by hanging the leg out of bed, ulceration or gangrene, ABPI usually <0.5Urgent vascular referral: analgesia, imaging → revascularisation (angioplasty or bypass); amputation if unreconstructable
Acute limb ischaemiaSudden onset, the 6 Ps — pain, pallor, pulselessness, perishing cold, paraesthesia, paralysisVascular emergency: oxygen, analgesia, IV heparin, immediate vascular referral → embolectomy, thrombolysis or bypass within hours
Spinal (neurogenic) claudicationRelieved by bending forward/downhill, associated back pain, numbness or weaknessConservative: physiotherapy, analgesia, weight loss. Surgical: lumbar decompression / laminectomy if disabling or progressive neurology
DVTUnilateral calf swelling, redness and warmth; may have chest pain/SOB if embolisedWells score and D-dimer → duplex ultrasound; anticoagulation. Thrombolysis or thrombectomy only for phlegmasia / limb-threatening iliofemoral DVT
SciaticaShooting pain down the back of the leg to the foot, with a history of back painConservative: analgesia, stay active, physiotherapy. Surgical: microdiscectomy for persistent or progressive radiculopathy
Musculoskeletal injuryClear history of trauma, localised tendernessConservative: rest, analgesia, physiotherapy. Surgery rarely required — e.g. for a complete tendon rupture
Osteoarthritis (hip/knee)Joint-localised pain, stiffness, not classically exercise-distance-dependentConservative: weight loss, physiotherapy, analgesia, intra-articular steroid. Surgical: joint replacement when conservative measures fail